Joe won

1998 | Las Vegas Film Critics Society Award
Most Promising Actor for Shakespeare in Love

1998 | Broadcast Film Critics Association Awards
Breakthrough Artist for Elizabeth

1999 | Screen Actors Guild Awards
Outstanding Performance by a Cast for Shakespeare in Love

1999 | Blockbuster Entertainment Awards
Favorite Male Newcomer for Shakespeare in Love

1999 | MTV Movie Awards
Best Kiss for Shakespeare in Love

1999 | Chicago Film Critics Association Awards
Most Promising Actor for Shakespeare in Love

2008 | Cinema For Peace Award
Most Valuable Short Film of the Year for The Spirit

Joe was nominated for

1999 | BAFTA Awards
Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role for Shakespeare in Love

1999 | MTV Movie Awards
Best Breakthrough Male Performance for Shakespeare in Love

1999 | Screen Actors Guild Awards
Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Leading Role for Shakespeare in Love

1999 | Teen Choice Awards
Film – Sexiest Love Scene for Shakespeare in Love

2005 | Satellite Awards
Best Actor in a Supporting Role, Comedy or Musical for The Merchant of Venice